Match Ratings For Smackdown On Fox 10/4/19 From Sean Ross Sapp

Opening segment

  • Vince and Stephanie McMahon welcome everyone to Smackdown
  • Becky Lynch comes out and kicks off the night by thanking the Staples Center and saying she's doing to kick someone's ass.
  • King Corbin comes out next. He trashes Becky Lynch, and she fires back at him.
  • The Rock comes out and cuts a promo about how the term Smackdown changed WWE.
  • He calls Baron Corbin a Burger King employee on crack.
  • Rock says winning King of The Ring doesn't make you a King, like Becky Lynch is "The Man" but doesn't carry around a pair of testicles. She says if she did they'd be bigger than Corbin. He says his testicles are perfectly adequate.
  • Becky hits Baron with the IT DOESN'T MATTER WHAT YOU THINK.
  • They call Baron a "super tough dude" and get the crowd to chant "STD."
  • They beat up Corbin. People's Elbow, Rock Bottom.

Charlotte Flair & Becky Lynch defeated Boss N' Hug Connection
6/10

  • The entrances look so much better with the updates.
  • Great action early on, Charlotte gets worked over.
  • Becky Lynch is in the ring after the break, and the crowd is hot.
  • This was a great idea for an opening match on Smackdown. All four of these women look like the stars they are.
  • Charlotte moonsaults outside onto Boss N Hug. She taps out Bayley.
  • The crowd pushed this up to rec'd viewing for me.

Backstage Crappenings

  • Erin Andrews interviews New Day. Erin Andrews not reading directly from a script felt so much better.
  • Trish Stratus, Lita, Mick Foley, Kurt Angle, Goldberg, Hulk Hogan, Ric Flair. Tyson Fury are at Smackdown.
  • I can't remember the last time I saw an action figure commercial during Raw or SD.
  • Market-specific ROH TV ads running during Smackdown on FOX.

Seth Rollins vs. Shinsuke Nakamura (w/ Sami Zayn)
N/A (Short)

  • Firefly Funhouse happens with Seth in the ring. The Rabbit warns Seth to not face The Fiend, and says he's a big Rollins fan. Mercy the Buzzard kills him.
  • Nakamura grabs a flying armbar.
  • If Seth Rollins has a "patented" suicide dive, he should be suing the whole roster for infringement.
  • Rollins missed a kick by a mile.
  • THE FIEND is here. They HAD to get The Fiend on this Smackdown.
  • I liked that for a number of reasons. Seth and Nakamura on the show, neither lost. It built the Sunday HIAC match, and got The Fiend on Fox. Everyone wins.

WWE 24/7 Title
Marshmello defeated Carmella (c) to become WWE 24/7 Champion
Carmella defeated Marsmello (c) to win the title

  • Marshmello is talking to R-Truth and the Bella Twins.
  • Carmella approaches and throw biscuits or something. Marshmello pins Carmella and wins the title.
  • Another Marshmello pins Marshmello. It's Carmella. She wins the title back.

Loser Leaves WWE
Ladder Match
Kevin Owens defeated Shane McMahon
7.25/10

  • Kevin Owens attacks Shane McMahon up the ramp.
  • Shane does his elbow drop through the announce table.
  • We come back from commercial to see Kevin Owens frog splash Shane McMahon through a bridged ladder!
  • WWE has some rough mic issues with the crowd. The crowd gets completely muted at times.
  • McMahon cracks Owens in the ankle with a chair.
  • Coast to Coast from Shane McMahon!
  • Owens powerbombs Shane into a ladder.
  • Shane McMahon is "fired" from WWE.
  • Kevin Owens fires Shane and hits him with a Stone Cold Stunner.

Braun Strowman, The Miz & Heavy Machinery defeated Dolph Ziggler, Bobby Roode, AJ Styles & Randy Orton
5/10

  • This is a good way to pack in a lot of talent.
  • The heels get their asses kicked pretty heavily.
  • Strowman mows EVERYONE down.
  • Strowman and Tyson Fury face off at ringside, leading to Ziggler jumping on Strowman
  • Strowman hits his finish for the win.
  • Tyson Fury jumps the guard rail and has to be held back!
  • This was AMAZING.

Lumberjack Match
Roman Reigns defeated Erick Rowan
5.75/10

  • The lumberjacks argue among themselves.
  • Daniel Bryan is on commentary.
  • Back from the commercial, this is very much a Greatest Hits of Roman Reigns and Rowan.
  • Harper comes out and Bryan goes right after him.
  • It's mayhem with the lumberjacks. Reigns jumps over the top onto all of them.
  • Rowan powerbombs Ali onto Reigns.
  • Harper and Bryan both run in, an Reigns hits a spear for the win.
  • The crowd was great for this.

WWE Championship
Brock Lesnar (w/ Paul Heyman) defeated Kofi Kingston (c)
SQUASH

  • F5. Pin.
  • Rey Mysterio comes out with Cain Velasquez
  • Velasquez attacks Lesnar.
  • I don't know that Brock Lesnar needed the title on him to feud with Cain Velasquez. Quite the opposite.
  • Not a fan of that unless Brock is defending more often. The top prize of a program not being on a show reduces the importance of the program.
  • They advertised a whole bunch of people who weren't on the show, and ended early.

Rating guide

10- Perfect, 9- MOTY Territory, 8- Excellent, 7- Great, 6- Good, 5- Average to above average, 4- Slightly below average, 3 or below: Poor

Each match starts at a 5 and slides up and down based on entertainment, execution, time, environment, reaction and stakes. The ratings are in no way an indication of a "star rating," which is a completely different system. A standard, non-offensive "TV match" lands at a 5. The gap between 5.75-6 is generally the largest, with anything reaching 6 being recommended viewing.
These are opinions, and incredibly inconsistent ones. Don't take them too seriously, and have (and share) your own!

Get exclusive pro wrestling content on Fightful Select, our premium news service! Click here to learn more.