Match Ratings For WWE Smackdown Live 6/11/19

Miz TV

  • Miz TV kicks off Smackdown Live, and calls Shane McMahon "Pest in the World."
  • Shane McMahon is joined by Drew McIntyre and Elias, but this is way too much Shane McMahon on WWE TV.
  • Shane is an okay heel, but he's way overexposed. I know WWE thinks that means he's got the right kind of heat, but before long, he won't.
  • Roman going after Drew is brought up, and McIntyre puts his Claymore over.
  • Shane McMahon's baked potato jokes still hit well.
  • This shit was the first 20 minutes of the television broadcast.
  • If Miz beats Elias and Drew, he gets to face Shane McMahon.
Eddie Kingston Discusses His Gear At AEW Full Gear, Wanting To Pay Tribute To Misawa

Gauntlet Match

  • Elias' ropewalk Meteora is great. So is his sitdown powerbomb.
  • This match lasts all of two minutes. Miz wins with a Skull Crushing Finale.
  • This made Elias look like a joke.

Elias is eliminated.

  • Drew McIntyre is up next, and he already lasts longer than Elias because the commercial break happens immediately.
  • Drew McIntyre overpowers Miz and hits a Claymore for the Win.

Miz is beaten

  • Shane McMahon gives Miz his match anyway.
  • Shane attacks and locks Miz in the triangle and gets the submission.

Heavy Machinery defeated The YOLO County Tag Team Champions

  • Daniel Bryan and Rowan are out to trash talk the YOLO County Tag Team Champions, but Heavy Machinery interrupts.
  • Heavy Machinery want a shot at the tag titles, but they're getting the YOLO Champs instead.
  • This is a squash. Otis hits the Worm.
  • Compactor Wins it.
  • Daniel Bryan keeps Rowan from attacking Heavy Machinery after the match.


  • R-Truth recaps his week to Carmella, and accidentally gets locked in a box.
  • Jinder Mahal impersonates Carmella when he finds Truth. This is Jinder Mahal's best work.
  • Jinder is going to find Truth after he's been loaded up to go to LA. Carmella can't find him.

Sonya Deville (w/ Mandy Rose) defeated Nikki Cross

  • Backstage, Fire & Desire troll Ember Moon some more. Sonya knocks a book out of Ember's hands. Ember does a hilarious scream and throws a trash can.
  • This is a match I'm stoked to see on Smackdown.
  • Sonya Deville's sliding knee is outstanding.
  • Carmella counters a jacknife pin into a Code of Silence.
  • Mandy puts Sonya's foot on the rope, but she just could have done it herself.
  • Sonya and Carmella are going hard in this match. Another great knee, a Sonya bump outside, and a Carmella suicide dive.
  • Sonya scores another knee for the win.
  • Carmella has gotten very good.

Backstage Crappenings

  • Aleister Black promo is basically me trying to get Alex to like anything in WWE.
  • Apollo cuts a promo about Andrade, and Zelina confronts him. She was great here. Gable is seen taking notes.

Bayley defeated Nikki Cross (w/ Alexa Bliss)

  • Alexa Bliss tells Nikki that there were hurtful things on social media said about her after the interference last night.
  • Okay, so this is all the Wild Cards, right? Nope
  • Bold of Bayley to do that sliding dropkick.
  • Nikki Cross' falling reverse DDT is good, glad to see that move used on TV again.
  • Bayley is really hard hitting, for better or for worse. She lays in her rope stunner and elbows. Sooner or later, I need to see Bayley in a strong style type match, because she already lays that shit in
  • Flying Elbow Drop wins it for Bayley.

New Day and HEELZ

  • I'm so glad Big E is back. Honestly, the two months flew by, and having him on TV a few weeks ago was a nice touch. Knee braceless Big E at that.
  • They make a "booking joke" about Charlotte, titles reigns, and flights to Charlotte, NC.
  • Ziggler cuts a crazy promo, and Owens follows, Zayn is hilarious when he's upset about New Day talking about his narrow behind.
  • What we don't need are two 15 minute promos on one show.
  • Kofi Kingston talking about all the times he beat people was really good. He exudes the qualities of a champion at this point.

New Day defeated Sami Zayn, Kevin Owens & Dolph Ziggler

  • Big E is officially back, and worked in the ring.
  • Dolph Ziggler has a hell of a dropkick.
  • Kofi is worked over for quite some time until Xavier Wood's excellent hot tag, complete with big lariat.
  • They're really playing up Big E's return hot tag.
  • This entire match is short babyface bursts, and sustained heel heat.
  • Owens does a nice second rope moonsault. This was very cool.
  • The Big E spot pays off and the crowd goes nuts.
  • Trouble in Paradise on Ziggler and Zayn and Zayn is pinned. This was solid.

Rating guide

10- Perfect, 9- MOTY Territory, 8- Excellent, 7- Great, 6- Good, 5- Average to above average, 4- Slightly below average, 3 or below: Poor

Each match starts at a 5 and slides up and down based on entertainment, execution, time, environment, reaction and stakes. The ratings are in no way an indication of a "star rating," which is a completely different system. A standard, non-offensive "TV match" lands at a 5.The gap between 5.75-6 is generally the largest, with anything reaching 6 being recommended viewing.
These are opinions, and incredibly inconsistent ones. Don't take them too seriously, and have (and share) your own!

Get exclusive combat sports content on Fightful Select, our premium news service! Click here to learn more.
From The Web