Match Ratings For WWE Smackdown Live 9/10/19 At MSG From Sean Ross Sapp

Taker

  • The Undertaker comes out and says he's called Madison Square Garden home for 30 years.
  • He says it's time to usher in a new era of Superstar.
  • Sami Zayn's music hits.
  • He comes out and talks his shit, per usual. He's heeling the crowd to set up to get his ass kicked.
  • Undertaker pretends he's going to leave before chokeslamming Sami Zayn.
Tony Khan Wears Neck Brace During 2024 NFL Draft

The Miz defeated Andrade (w/ Zelina)
5/10

  • Miz is a walking commercial for his reality show right now and that's it.
  • Shinsuke Nakamura is on commentary, which I love.
  • We get two commercials pretty early and come back to Miz doing the IT kicks.
  • I get Miz being in this spot because of history and his reality show, but this isn't a great performance from him and Andrade is outstanding.
  • The Miz tosses Andrade over the announce table onto Nakamura. This is a great spot.
  • Miz blows the finisher spot out of the double moonsault.
  • This was not great.
  • Nakamura comes in and hits his finish on the Miz.

Nikki Cross (w/ Alexa Bliss) defeated Mandy Rose (w/ Sonya Deville)
5.25/10

  • Mandy Rose gets ZERO heat for saying she's pretty and Nikki Cross is ugly. Almost like it's a shitty line.
  • Who............the...........................fuuuuuu........wrote.......this.....promo. It's so dumb
  • Whoever is writing this "YOU'LL NEVER LOOK LIKE ME" shit for Mandy, stop. It's bad.
  • Nikki Cross gets a good pop when Alexa brings her out, and she's on fire.
  • Sonya Deville distracts Nikki, but Mandy is rolled up after a missed Bicycle knee.
  • That was a good short match that had to battle through the rainstorm of dialogue shit that was written for Mandy.

Heavy Machinery crushes Jobbers
Squash

  • Tucker shows off his agility and KILLS Jon Silver.
  • Otis is tagged in and does his Caterpillar.
  • An assisted powerslam and Compactor gets it done.

Reigns and Rowan

  • "You see" three times in the first 30 seconds of the promo is promising
  • "All you people."
  • Roman Reigns comes out and brawls with Rowan into the crowd.
  • Reigns does Superman punches on Rowan.
  • Erick Rowan stealing Jordynne Grace's fanslamming gimmick. Steve Harvey has Eric Bischoff SHOOK.
  • Rowan took out a whole bunch of staff, and slams a jib camera into Reigns' face.
  • The promo was terrible, but the brawl ruled.

Bayley defeated Ember Moon
5/10 (short)

  • Ember Moon confronts Bayley. She doesn't like who Bayley has been lately. Ember's dialogue is wooden, but improving.
  • Charlotte Flair is watching on.
  • Some hard hitting stuff out of Ember Moon, but she's about to lose again.
  • Bayley-to-Belly, that's it.
  • All the good matches last night, none tonight so far.

A Decade Later

  • Kofi Kingston runs down his MSG history.
  • Randy Orton interrupts Kofi and calls him stupid, and says he's always been a phony.
  • "Whether it was the fake accent or that phony power of positivity shit."
  • Orton takes a chair to Kofi, but the tides are turned.
  • They GOTTA run the table spot back in MSG.
  • Oh noooooooooo the table broke when Kofi got up.
  • A super awesome spot that WWE made almost unwatchable because of terrible camera work

King of the Ring Semifinals
Special Ref: Kevin Owens
Two out of three falls
Chad Gable defeated Shane McMahon 2-0
5.75/10

  • Why would you have Chad Gable say that he's expecting a bye in the tournament? It makes him look dumb, and like a coward. Shane says Elias will have a replacement tonight. It ends up being Shane.
  • Shane tells Kevin Owens that if he helps him win tonight as referee, his $100,000 fine will go away. Owens isn't happy about having to do this.
  • Shane McMahon is making a bunch of short jokes.
  • Chad Gable SQUASHED Shane McMahon.
  • Kevin Owens counts the pinfall.
  • Shane McMahon demands the match be made two out of three falls.
  • He attacks Gable and slams him into the table, working him over during the break.
  • Shane scolds Owens. But then, why would Owens have counted the fall at all? He counts slow for Gable and fast for Shane.
  • Nobody can sell Gable's rolling kick. He MAKES Shane sell the rolling neckbreaker.
  • Owens counts slow for a moonsault from Gable.
  • Shane can't win with a rack neckbreaker and a fast count.
  • Owens stops Shane from using a chair.
  • Gable applies an Ankle Lock and wins!
  • Shane McMahon attacks Owens from behind.
  • Shane McMahon "fires" Kevin Owens

Rating guide

10- Perfect, 9- MOTY Territory, 8- Excellent, 7- Great, 6- Good, 5- Average to above average, 4- Slightly below average, 3 or below: Poor

Each match starts at a 5 and slides up and down based on entertainment, execution, time, environment, reaction and stakes. The ratings are in no way an indication of a "star rating," which is a completely different system. A standard, non-offensive "TV match" lands at a 5. The gap between 5.75-6 is generally the largest, with anything reaching 6 being recommended viewing.
These are opinions, and incredibly inconsistent ones. Don't take them too seriously, and have (and share) your own!

Get exclusive pro wrestling content on Fightful Select, our premium news service! Click here to learn more.